Chris’ Review:
I know what you are all thinking. No this isn’t a review on the epic film from 1979 starring William…Shatner…as Captain…Kirk. (Those were the overly dramatic pauses. I hope you all heard his voice in your head just like I did. Unless it will make you r other voices jealous.) The movie for review is actually the new release film of this year. It still features the old characters but with a whole new cast. To same some time I will assume we are all familiar with Star Trek. If not, then stop reading this go obtain an education. Either at the video store, netflix, any of a bazillion conventions, or over 10 bazillion websites. No we won’t wait for you to get back, you will just have to catch-up when you are ready. For the rest of you who stayed we will now review this movie.
The plot is very Treklike. We finally get to see what Kirk was like when he cheated at the Academy. He ends up on the Enterprise under the command of Captain Pike. They go on a mission and much calamity ensues.
Now first I want to say I enjoyed this movie. The special effects were spectacular. The acting was solid. So much so that I didn’t even notice the absence of a painfully overacted Kirk. (Ah Will Shatner. You get us those hotel deals and leave space travel to the kids. thanks). It is the plot where I have a few issues. First off Kirk was under investigation for academic misconduct. Yet he somehow is allowed to remain on board and gets promoted to first officer…..I know a lot of military people and was unaware that this is how one gets promoted. “Oh by the way crew, I know many of you have served honorably for years and worked your way up the ranks but I am handing the flagship of the fleet to a kid who hasn’t finished the academy and is looking at possible expulsion because he can’t follow orders and regulations.” Hmmm if any of you are former military and can confirm this system please do so. My other issue involves Chekov. This is only because I am a Trekkie purist, but Chekov didn’t arrive until later in the series. This is the basis for one of the biggest Star Trek arguments of all time. How did Khan know who Chekov was in the second movie.
Now I know what you are thinking…..”Get over it dud this movie rocked.” Well I have to agree with you. It wouldn’t be a Star Trek movie if there weren’t plot holes you could fly a starship through. Besides, it makes for good movie watching. There were some good quotes and the movie itself was easily worth watching again and again.
I think this movie gets 4.8 stars. The plot holes don’t keep it from being viewable, but they do detract a little and prevent the 5 star rating. So live long and prosper and stay tuned for the next review which will be G.I.Joe Rise of Cobra.
Toni’s Review:
Yes, I know this is waaaaayyyyy past due. Sue me. Life gets in the way sometimes, as much as I fight it.
Star Trek…What to say that has not already been said? Well, to counter Chris, which I do love to do, I’ll say that I’m not a fan of the original series. So, I guess that makes this easier for me. I know almost nothing about the original crew, other than the obvious ones that no one can avoid. I didn’t know that Chekov didn’t enter the series until later, and I don’t really care. Besides, all of that can be explained by the rationalization that this movie is an ALTERNATE TIME LINE! Everything can be manipulated to fit what the writers and director want, because this is a complete reboot of the series!
The plot is solid, time-traveling Romulans have come back to destroy Vulcan in return for Spock (Nemoy, not Quinto) allowing Romulus to be destroyed in the future that they came from. Confusing, huh? Eric Bana plays a delightfully disarming Nero, captain of the Romulan mining vessel that is causing all of this death and destruction. Nero is also the cause of Jim Kirk’s father’s death early in the film, and the first of many time line shifts begins.
Kirk (Pine) is everything I always expected. Very ‘devil-may-care’, charming, sexy, and a bit of an ass at times. I do believe that I fell a bit in love with him, as I’m finding happens often. Spock (Quinto, or as we all know him, Sylar) is creepily uninvolved and detached, but with an air of barely restrained contempt and violence swarming around him. Vulcans always creeped me out, and he is no exception.
The other characters, Scotty (Pegg), Bones (Urban), Chekov (Yelchin), Sulu (Cho), Uhura (Saldana) and many others are witty and charming, and I loved every single one of them.
The few issues that I took with the film include: Why does the Enterprise have the immense waste of space in its design? There is so much in the set pieces that make no sense, such as the huge water tanks…Good scene, crappy concept.
My final verdict for this movie? A solid 4.9 out of 5…while not perfect, it’s pretty damn close.